Understanding the Impact of Masculinity on Teenage Boys’ Learning | GIS Blog

Every child deserves to learn and thrive: What to believe and what to question? | GIS Blog
May 16, 2017
Keeping Your Child Safe Online | Garden International School Malaysia
May 16, 2017
Home > School Life > GIS Blog > Understanding the Impact of Masculinity on Teenage Boys’ Learning | GIS Blog
back to blog

Understanding the Impact of Masculinity on Teenage Boys’ Learning | GIS Blog

By Jack Campbell, Mathematics Teacher

Gender is a significant factor that affects the social, emotional and academic development of young people. At Garden International School (GIS), staff are conscious of both the similarities and differences in how boys and girls develop socially, emotionally and academically and have an acute awareness of the influence that gender-related factors have on teenagers in particular.

The link between gender and academic achievement has been the subject of a significant body of research that traces its history at least as far back as John Locke who, in 1693, expressed his concern at what he considered the ‘underachievement’ of boys in their studies of French, Latin, and Ancient Greek. This is a something still seen today- in almost all economically developed countries, females outperform males at secondary school as measured by virtually any available metric.

To fully support the education of teenage boys and to help reduce this achievement gap, an effort must be made to understand the dominant views and ideas that relate to masculinity within society. Many of these ideas are so ingrained in us we are constantly influenced by them, often without us realising. This set of dominant views is known as ‘hegemony’ and differs between cultures, groups, families and indeed between schools. In many Western cultures, research suggests that the hegemonic view of masculinity, particularly amongst young people, is centered on characteristics not necessarily conducive to academic success- for instance, toughness, humour and being attractive to females as well as a tendency to withdraw effort in order to ‘save face’ when confronted with the possibility of ‘failure’.

Hegemony also has the potential to negatively influence a student’s emotional development. Students who do not identify with the dominant ideas of masculinity that they are consciously and subconsciously exposed to can be the victims of bullying and their emotional health may suffer, something compounded by the fact that many hegemonies of masculinity discourage males from talking about their feelings.

At GIS, teachers and school leaders recognise that they can play a role in helping shape an inclusive hegemony and have helped create an environment that supports healthy and diverse forms of masculinity which in turn contributes to boys’ positive academic and social development. Parents too play an important role and to fully support the emotional and academic development of their sons, they must be conscious of the ideas of masculinity that they implicitly and explicitly promote.

Given the pervasive nature of hegemony, parents and teachers must recognise that they are just two pieces of a very large puzzle and that society as a whole plays a large role in endorsing certain forms of masculinity above others, something particularly true in the age of social media in which boys are exposed to literally thousands more images per week than they would have been as little as ten years ago. However, strong partnerships between parents and educators as well as an awareness of the impact that concepts of masculinity can have on teenagers will help secure the social and academic development of our young men.

Jack Campbell has taught Mathematics at Garden International School since August 2015 and is heavily involved in supporting students applying to the Universities of Oxford and Cambridge. Before that, he taught for three years at an all boys’ state school in inner-city Manchester in the UK. He completed his undergraduate degree in Philosophy, Politics, and Economics at the University of Oxford in 2009 and completed his Masters in Education at the University of Manchester in 2015. His dissertation focused on ‘laddishness’ and perceptions of education amongst Asian Muslim teenage boys.
GIS Blog